H: Jonathan Bennett
R1: They had to make three dozen cookies- one filled, one festive & one frosted.
Jen Musty (S.F.):
Filled: Shortbread I.C. sandwich
Festive: 3-D shortbread tree
Frosted: Snowball
Megan Greulich (St. Paul):
Filled: Sweet potato whoopie pie
Festive: Bacon pecan snickerdoodle
Frosted: Iced Earl Grey
Dani Fiori (Martha Stewart's resident cookie expert from Weehawken, NJ):
Filled: NONE ON PLATE
Festive: Red velvet & sugar cookie candy cane
Frosted: Peppermint sugar
Tarsha Joyner (Lynchburg, VA software support analyst):
Filled: Chocolate peppermint Alfajare
Festive: Snowball
Frosted: Pumpkin
Jake Hoffart (former football player in SAC):
Filled: Mint & fudge
Festive: Frosted molasses gingerbread
Frosted: Chocolate "crackle" fudge
R2: Two dozen cookies were needed this time- one ooey-gooey & the other soft & chewy.
Tarsha:
O-G: Chocolate dipped caramel-covered shortbread
S&C: Coconut macaroon
Megan:
O-G: Chocolate espresso w/ peppermint schnapps Anglaise
S&C: P.B. oatmeal
Jake:
O-G: Chocolate chip w/ caramel
S&C: Buttercream-frosted pumpkin
Jen:
O-G: Double chocolate espresso caramel
S&C: Apple-spiced blondie
OUT 2ND- Jake
FR:
Megan: Christmas music
Jen: Life in the North Pole
Tarsha: Winter wonderland
W- Tarsha
R1: They had to make three dozen cookies- one filled, one festive & one frosted.
Jen Musty (S.F.):
Filled: Shortbread I.C. sandwich
Festive: 3-D shortbread tree
Frosted: Snowball
Megan Greulich (St. Paul):
Filled: Sweet potato whoopie pie
Festive: Bacon pecan snickerdoodle
Frosted: Iced Earl Grey
Dani Fiori (Martha Stewart's resident cookie expert from Weehawken, NJ):
Filled: NONE ON PLATE
Festive: Red velvet & sugar cookie candy cane
Frosted: Peppermint sugar
Tarsha Joyner (Lynchburg, VA software support analyst):
Filled: Chocolate peppermint Alfajare
Festive: Snowball
Frosted: Pumpkin
Jake Hoffart (former football player in SAC):
Filled: Mint & fudge
Festive: Frosted molasses gingerbread
Frosted: Chocolate "crackle" fudge
R2: Two dozen cookies were needed this time- one ooey-gooey & the other soft & chewy.
Tarsha:
O-G: Chocolate dipped caramel-covered shortbread
S&C: Coconut macaroon
Megan:
O-G: Chocolate espresso w/ peppermint schnapps Anglaise
S&C: P.B. oatmeal
Jake:
O-G: Chocolate chip w/ caramel
S&C: Buttercream-frosted pumpkin
Jen:
O-G: Double chocolate espresso caramel
S&C: Apple-spiced blondie
OUT 2ND- Jake
FR:
Megan: Christmas music
Jen: Life in the North Pole
Tarsha: Winter wonderland
W- Tarsha